What games make smile when you remember pwning some friends in playing games for the sake of it. For me HOMM3 was installed again, and I love it, I think its the best in the series. (as a matter of fact, I'm going to go play now, I'll check back every once and a while)
You know, I don't think much can beat a four-player, split screen, Goldeneye 007 tournament. True classic.
I am also quite partial to a good game of impossible creatures by relic, its a little known game in which you combine creatures in various ways and do battle through them. Although you'll nearly never find anyone else playing it :/
I know SC is still played but due to being 10 years old I consider it a nostalgic game. Also old mechwarrior games and Diablo 1
ditto, though my sister always won using link, my only chance was to use mario or falco because they could easily attack her when she used the up + B attack (her favorite move).
HoMM3 ftw! Countless hours spent on it. Warcraft 1 and 2 are also there, gotta love the music in second
I remember playing Secret of Mana with my Cousin... in one session from start to beginning. Still one of my favourite SNES Games.
Solitaire. XD Just kidding. ;D I still like playing TMNT on the Atari (or is it the family computer console?)
Diablo, the very first one. I miss the days when all characters actually went through dungeons together rather than doing baal runs, etc. Oh yeah! Quake Team Fortress, I spent hours on that =P
Contra! One of the best games for NES Just found out that new one is being made Oo http://ds.gamespy.com/nintendo-ds/contra-4/
Can a game still count as Nostalgic if you still play it? If so, I would say Zeus & Posiden. If not, Skies of Arcadia and Black and White are tied. On a related note, I read from EGM that Skies of Arcadia is getting a sequal.